Embeded WindowsMediaPlayer has bugs

Hot Topic

Moving user controls on a panel has strange consequences...
beta 2 - Negative Min value causes error
Enabling a tool bar Via MDI Child
Excel 2002 problem
report depending on a certain information
DataGrid Paing
Open form in splitcontainer
how to enumerate over all controlls on one form
Issue with DataGridView DataErrors raised
Create Image from Icon

Windows Forms

Databinding - datarelations - textbox
TreeView & ListView contols
How to update a tables-Joined tableAdapter via DataGridView
User Control loading
"Unknown Publisher"
Best Practice - How to populate combobox dropdown lists from the same datatable
Datagridview Printing
Is there a way to fire an event programmatically?
user control problem
Form that carries loads of data - looking for the best practice?

Embeded WindowsMediaPlayer has bugs

Summary: The AxWMPLib.AxWindowsMediaPlayer object seems to have bugs and becomes unstable.

Question:  Is there a bug on the Active X wrapper that is generated by Visual Studio   Do anyone know of a workaround

Background:
I am using an embedded Windows Media Player in a form.  I got the player onto the from via the VS Designer. 

The instance of the player object is of type AxWMPLib.AxWindowsMediaPlayer m_player.

When I set the URL property (e.g. m_player.URL = "c:\my_wav_file.wav" ) the player starts playing but then after a few seconds the progress bar of the player jumps back to the beginning and becomes grey (disabled) although the audio keeps playing.  Once the position marker got into the disabled state if you click on it the audio starts playing from the begining.

If you keep repeating the process of assigning new wav files to the URL property after some stage the player object crash.

The only code I wrote myself other than what was created by the VS Designer, was to set the URL.


Any help or suggested on the following questions will be appreciated:
Is this a known problem   
Do anyone knows of a workaround   
Will this be fixed after the beta  
Is there a different way of using the Media Player by not using the VS Active X wrapper

At this stage, the only way to get stable playback working from VS 2005 beta 2 is to not use the URL method of the media player object, but instead launch the Media player window by calling the <openPlayer> method.  Unfortunally then, you don't have any programmatic control over the playback since it runs as a seperate application. 

As things are now you can't develop a serious media application with VS 2005.

Product Versions:
- VS 2005 beta 2
- Windows Media Player 10
- Windows XP

Answer this question

Embeded WindowsMediaPlayer has bugs

  • adi

    This sounds like a potential product bug.  Please use the MSDn product feedback center to open a bug for this issue.

    http://lab.msdn.microsoft.com/ProductFeedback/

    thanks
    - mike

  • Abdul Sami

    I have seen this problem before playing movie files in Windows Media Player itself. I have always had the feeling that it had something to do with the movie file, but i know nothing about media file formats, so I wouldnt know how to go about figuring that out.

    Unfortunately, I cant find a place to report bugs in WMP. Any of the MS gurus here know where to report this kind of thing



  • B_Free

    The bug was reported at the MSDN feedback center.

    Microsoft responded with the following feedback regarding the bug report (2005-07-06 ):

    "We have been able to repro this issue and are investigating."

    "This issue appears to be related to a bug in the Windows Media Player control and not to the Active X wrapper. Because of this there isn't anything we can change on our code to cause it to work better."

    This error means that Windows Media Player can't be used in VS .Net applications as an embedded control.


    In summary the behaviour for this bug:

    • The player starts playing.
    • The position control start moving.
    • After a few seconds the position marker stops although the player continues to play.
    • If you click on the position marker the audio start playing from the start and the position marker stays stuck at the beginning while the player is playing.

    Question:

    Can anyone please help to send this bug to the right person at Microsoft


  • Blkbird

    I'm seeing the same thing with MPG files from a Sony W70 camera (video files from the camera). I have a 40 second video that plays fine on Nero, but when using Windows Media Player, the video stops 1/4th the way through but the audio keeps going. What's odd is that when Windows Media Player loads the file, it only recognizes it to be the length at which it stops... ie, even though it stop 25% of the way through, the video bar doesn't reflect that. It reflects that it played 100% of the video... but the audio keeps playing for another minute which is very odd.

    Any clues

    -ken

  • lpasquali

    I embedded wmp in a web page

    script was player.openplayer(URL)

    make sure that the wmpAx is in pause then you can click the event

    for the external player

  • jeffandmarc

    I don't think jsre is revering to the same problem.

    I veried that the same bug exists when Media Player Control version 11 is used.

    The bugs behaviour:

  • The player starts playing.
  • The position control start moving.
  • After a few seconds the position marker stops although the player continues to play.
  • If you click on the position marker the audio start playing from the start and the position marker stays stuck at the beginning while the player is playing.

  • Fozya

    Is this bug fixed now (10/24/2006)

    I cannot build "AxWMPLib.AxWindowsMediaPlayer m_player".

    VS could not find such references: ComLib, WMPLib, OcxControls, and AxWMPlib.

    Thanks.



  • Embeded WindowsMediaPlayer has bugs
    • Answer this question