SQL 2005 BI Capabilities

I am looking for any information available that would give comparison between SQL Server 2005 BI capabilities/features and other tier 1 products such as Business Objects, Cognos, etc.... Has anyone come across anything yet Things I am looking for are more along the lines of the metadata information. I have found that Business Objects has an impressive tool called Data Integrator and was wondering what SQL 2005 has in comparison to this tool...thanks!!

Answer this question

SQL 2005 BI Capabilities

  • Yogesh Ranade

    Thanks for the reply Jamie, both the links on the blog are dead :)

    I will go to the forrester site and see what I can find.

    What I am r-e-a-l-l-y looking for is what microsoft has in 2005 that would give some of the same funtionality the Data Integrator does, things like giving you a way to track the impact of changes to a data item/column in a table, metadata documentation, you can drill down to a particular data item, and actually apply a comment to the item to explain what it is, ability to track a piece of data from a report back to the source that it came from, all of which lead to better internal control, and a better chance at getting to a "single truth" (although I feel that is a dream at times) so you can have a single source of data to reduce time spent on the ever popular excercise  of tracking back to why this report doesn't match that report....have you seen the Data Integrator tool

    Anyway, just hoping someone else has been down this path, I will be installing 2005 in the next month so I will dig through it at some point anyway. Thanks again


  • Gohan222

    Hi Darren, sorry but what you see in this thread is all I have to date. I was at a conference a couple weeks ago and there was a demo of the microsoft suite at the conference. I would say that it definetly warrents a good review. It appears pretty comprehensive, and if you are already using SQL Server and plan to upgrade to 2005, you need to look at it. As far as the metadata management I am uncertain of all of the capabilities, but with SSIS, and the new Business Scorecard Manager, I think from a pricing standpoint it will be very competitive. Let me know if you run into any good info, will do the same. Thanks
  • ManchesterMike

    While this doesn’t directly answer your question about metadata management support in SSIS (there are others more qualified to answer this and I will point this thread out to them), I do feel compelled to point out that from a BI platform point of view SQL Server provides a complete set of BI tools and servers. SQL Server 2005 includes Integration Services, Analysis Services and Reporting Services and between these you get support for ETL, OLAP, Data Mining and Reporting along with a full blown professional development environment.

    The synergy between these technologies extends to shared and consistent metadata.

    If you haven’t already, take a look at http://www.microsoft.com/sql/solutions/bi/default.mspx .


  • David Teitlebaum MSFT

    SQL Server's competitor to Data Integrator is the product that this forum is dedicated to - SSIS. So you're in the right place.

    If you want an impartial view of what SSIS has to offer I have a link to a good article on my blog here: http://blogs.conchango.com/jamiethomson/archive/2005/02/28/1082.aspx in the comments section.

    -Jamie


  • Tan Silliksaar

    Hi

    I wonder if you have managed to get any further information here.  I work for a UK law firm and we are looking to build our first Datawarehouse. We currently use Crystal Reports and Crystal Enterprise for our current reporting requirements and BO consultancies who have shown us the BO Data Integrator and I agree with you that the meta data functionality was excellent and key feature. Its also being sold as an easy to use tool for non-technical staff.  However I see SQL 2005 IS as a possible alternative that will also save us money.  A doc comparing the 2 products would be excellent but I doubt anyone has done this.  If you have gathered any further info since you posted your message and willing to share I would be most grateful.

    Thanks
    Darren

  • SQL 2005 BI Capabilities